Why Your Website Isn't Converting

by Joel Freckelton, Full Stack Developer

1. You're Speaking to Everyone, So You're Connecting with No One

Generic messaging is the silent killer of conversions. When your homepage tries to appeal to every possible customer, it ends up resonating with none of them. Visitors make snap judgments in seconds—if they don't immediately see themselves reflected in your messaging, they're gone.

The solution isn't better copywriting tricks; it's ruthlessly specific positioning that speaks directly to your ideal customer's exact situation.

Top tip

A website that says "we help growing e-commerce brands reduce cart abandonment" will always outperform one that says "we help businesses succeed online."

2. Your User Journey Assumes Too Much Knowledge

You know your product inside and out, but your visitors are encountering it for the first time with zero context. Most websites jump straight to features and pricing without establishing why the visitor should care or what problem is actually being solved.

This creates cognitive friction—people have to work too hard to understand your value proposition.

Every extra second of confusion is another opportunity for them to hit the back button. Map out your user journey assuming complete ignorance, and guide visitors from "I have this problem" to "This solves my problem" to "I want this solution" in crystal-clear steps.

3. You're Optimizing for Clicks Instead of Trust

Conversion rate optimization has conditioned us to think that the right button color or clever urgency tactic will solve everything.

But if visitors don't fundamentally trust your business, no amount of A/B testing will fix your conversion problem. Trust is built through specificity, proof, and transparency—detailed case studies, real client names, candid explanations of your process, and honest discussions of who you're NOT right for. Ironically, the websites that convert best often include sections that actively discourage the wrong customers from buying. When you stop trying to trick people into converting and start building genuine credibility, the right customers will convert themselves

More articles

Workflow Bottlenecks Costing Your Team (And How to Fix Them)

If your team is copying and pasting information between different platforms—CRM to spreadsheets, emails to project management tools, invoices to accounting software—you're hemorrhaging productivity.

Read more

The ROI of Custom Software vs. Off-the-Shelf Solutions

What looked like a $50/month bargain can easily balloon into thousands annually when you factor in lost productivity and the additional tools you need to make it actually work

Read more

Tell us about your project

Our offices

Prefer doing things in person? Let's meet for coffee.

  • Los Angeles
    Abott Kinney Blvd
    Los Angeles, CA
  • Canada
    Spring Garden Road
    Halifax, NS